Compare Swatches
Steph's Closet Nail Polish Blog & Photo Gallery

Tuesday, September 8th, 2009

Halloween Collection: Milani Black Magic

Milani Black Magic Nail Lacquer

Collection: Milani Black Magic, Nail Lacquer 0.45 oz
Price: $3.49/ea
Steph's Rating: Steph's 4.5 Kisses Rating
Buy it: Meijer, CVS or other Stores

Hope y'all had a wonderful Labor Day weekend! It's dreary and rainy on this Tuesday afternoon. The good news, it's a short week for us work-goers. Let's ring in the new season with a drugstore favorite of mine, Milani.

Halloween is undoubtedly one of my favorite holidays of the year, so it's no surprise I fell over heels for Milani's new Black Magic Collection. Aside from this new Fall collection, Milani hit the scene with two more limited edition releases sure to love, Vintage and Welcome Back Color.

In Black Magic, you'll find two qualities I adore: Black and Glitter, Yes Glittah! Each color is based in a thin, semi-sheer black jelly loaded with sparkling glitter. My Application was like most Milani's - smooth, excellent and dries to a non gritty finish. Noted below, you'll find the average coat-age on my swatches.

Let's down to biz-nass, shall we?

Milani Magical nail polish swatch

Milani Black Magic nail polish collection

Magical - A Black jelly loaded with brown glitter.

Milani Fairy Tale nail polish

Milani Black Magic Halloween Collection

Fairy Tale - A Black loaded with blue glitter. 

Milani Charmed Nail Polish Swatch

Milani Halloween Nail Polish Collection

Charmed - A Black with loaded silver glitter. 

Milani Enchantment Nail Polish Swatch

Enchantment - A Black with "ink" blue glitter. 

Milani Whimsical Nail Polish Swatch

Milani Black Magic Nail Polish Collection

Whimsical - A Black jelly loaded with purple glitter. 

Milani Spellbinding Nail Polish

Milani Halloween Nail Polish Collection

Spellbinding - A Black jelly loaded with red glitter.

Before you ask about dupes, I haven't pulled out any glitters to officially compare. But, I can probably think of around 20 look-alikes off the top of my head.

Milani's Black Magic Collection should be available at stores for a limited time only.

Do we have any Milani fans? What's your favorite drugstore brand? 

(18) Comments

Missrayz said on Sep 8th, 2009 1:14 pm
I found the milani display at cvs and picked up fairytale and whimsical. They also had out the welcome back to color display and i got sparkling blue and flamboyant in green (dont you just love that name, flamboyant in green!!) Steph, if you havent already seen flamboyant, it it is gorgeous!

Judy said on Sep 8th, 2009 1:16 pm
I tried Milani a couple months back and was unhappy with it. But I bought six of the Welcome Back Color collection, so I'm willing to give it another shot!! These are nice colors, but I will probably skip!

Steph said on Sep 10th, 2009 11:50 pm
Really? Aww, I love Milani! Hopefully you'll have better luck the second go around :)

dwj said on Sep 8th, 2009 1:28 pm
Well damn, this made me want to get up and go straight to my CVS. These colors are pretty gorgeous and the price is right. Love it!

rmcandlelight said on Sep 8th, 2009 1:37 pm
Lovely...spellbound looks like garnet gems.

Rosebee said on Nov 3rd, 2009 10:25 am
rmcandlelight: 27a Garnet Gems by Milani!!! My thoughts exactly. As far as the new "limited edition" colours, I got 139 radiant In Purple(LOVE) and 140 Shimmering Purple(so-so). My complaint w/ 140SP is that the bars/strips of glitter (not the round typical glitter) ended up near the edge of my nail and caused the polish to rip off nearly 12 hrs. later. ~Peace~

Lindsey said on Sep 8th, 2009 3:10 pm
those are gorgeous! could you do some comparison swatches?

Lucy said on Sep 8th, 2009 3:19 pm
I've never tried Milani. I may have to with all that glittah. But I'll wait to see if there are any dupes. They do look like familiar colours. I like Whimsical, Spellbinding and Magical. I await your dupe post.

Niki said on Sep 8th, 2009 3:44 pm
Oooh, just as pretty as I anticipated! I went to CVS yesterday, mine doesn't have these in yet. They only had one collection in, I picked up three polishes from it. I'll be on the lookout for the other two, especially this. I'm such a sucker for black with glitter! I think I like all of these. Haha. I actually have had great luck with Milani polishes, I really like them. Wet N Wild are hit or miss for me, but I'd say more hit than miss. I've only a couple Rimmel I like, but my fave so far has been Sally Hansen.

Stephanie said on Sep 8th, 2009 4:21 pm
You mentioned a limited edition collection called Welcome Back Color...what does that collection look like? I'm really loving Magical. Milani is a great brand but I don't have many of them for some reason.

echo7 said on Sep 8th, 2009 5:26 pm
Do these dry smooth or are they bumpy? I like glitters that dry smooth, otherwise I tend not to get them. I love a lot of these colors!

Steph said on Sep 10th, 2009 11:54 pm
These dry perfectly smooth, you'll love them!

Candihart said on Sep 8th, 2009 9:02 pm
I have these on the way and I'm soooo excited! Great swatches as usual Steph!

Dee said on Sep 8th, 2009 10:07 pm
Thanks for the swatches, that is really helpful for when I can actually find these darn things in my area! I want Magical, since I don't have anything like that at all.

Steph said on Sep 11th, 2009 12:01 am
Your so welcome! Magical is well, Magical! It's one of my faves :)

Judy said on Sep 13th, 2009 3:04 pm
Ok, so I tried the Welcome Back Color collection this week and I have a whole new opinion on Milani. I must've gotten a couple bad polishes before. I liked the WBC collection so much I even scored a couple of these Black Magic polishes(Whimsical, Magical and Fairy Tale)! I'll be linking back to your post here in my post on the Welcome Back Color polishes :) Thanks!

Angel Luv said on Oct 29th, 2009 10:27 pm
I really want to order the Milani Black magic collection on line but cannot find it anywhere I searched and searched. The CVS stores in my area do not have them. Help!

Steph said on Nov 3rd, 2009 11:30 am
Hi Angel Luv,
The Black Magic Collection is now available on! Hope this helps! :)

Connect with Facebook

Post Your Comment

(Not Published)

Follow StephsCloset on Twitter Become a Fan on Facebook Subscribe to Youtube
Login, contact and learn more about my passion!
Latest feedback from my loyal readers

Patricia said, on Sep 26th, 2012 12:11 pm regarding Product Review: Red Carpet Manicure Pro Kit
Hi Steph,
Love your blog. You wrote: Always wrap the free edge or tip throughout each step. I didn't see this step in the video. Could you please explain how to do the wrap process and with what material. Thank you.

Megan said, on Sep 8th, 2012 1:12 am regarding Product Review: Red Carpet Manicure Pro Kit
I am wondering if these gel polishes can be used with other gels. I have a different system with a different brand of base coat and top coat, can the different brands of gel mix?

Shelly said, on Aug 19th, 2012 3:43 pm regarding Product Review: Red Carpet Manicure Pro Kit
I've had my kit for a couple of months now and love the way it lasts; but the Structure and Brilliance brushes are starting to stiffen and so is the gel in the bottles. Anyone else having that issue? Is there a way to thin them out?

Jill said, on Aug 8th, 2012 5:47 pm regarding Product Review: Red Carpet Manicure Pro Kit
Hi, does anyone know if I can thin out the red carpet base coat so that it is easier to apply?

Steph said, on Jul 3rd, 2012 4:14 pm regarding Wet n Wild Flash Dry Nail Colors
Hi Prinzy,
It was a gorgeous color! I remember picking up a few bottles because I loved the color so much! lol! Actually, yes, I'm launching a store in the next couple of weeks. I have everything built, I'm just working on the Terms and Conditions right now, so it should be very, very soon.

I only have about 10 Studio M colors in the store currently, but I will be taking special pre-orders once it opens.

prinzy said, on Jul 3rd, 2012 3:47 pm regarding Wet n Wild Flash Dry Nail Colors
I missed out on speed, looks like a gorgeous high-end purple. btw, are you still thinking of selling studio m nail polishes on your website? thanks

sarah said, on Jun 14th, 2012 8:03 am regarding Summer Collection: China Glaze Poolside
thanks :)

Steph said, on Jun 13th, 2012 2:04 pm regarding Summer Collection: China Glaze Poolside
Hi Sarah,
I'm not sure about retail stores, but you can still find them on

Sarah said, on Jun 12th, 2012 2:19 pm regarding Summer Collection: China Glaze Poolside
Can I still buy them in the stores now?

Debra said, on May 26th, 2012 4:59 pm regarding Product Review: Red Carpet Manicure Pro Kit
I've been playing with this system for about a month now. I love it! When I first started I used the clear just so I could get a feel for it. Then I got adventurous and tried a "sandwich" with a China Glaze color. It probably would have stayed on longer if I had been able to seal off the edges, but my nails were so short it was a bit difficult. The next time I used RCM gel polish in Simply Stunning (a pale slightly shimmery nude color). This time I had gotten enough practice to really make my coats thin and it worked out fabulous. I'm trying to send all my friends the Ulta 20% coupon (5/26 is the last day) so they can get a kit for about $64. :) Now I hope to get a little creative with color combos and nail design. Thanks for the review.

Read Past Blog Entries
Find what you need organized nicely
View subscribers or subscribe yourself!
Browse awesome images in the photo gallery
Link Love
Sendin' love to all my favorite divas!
Subscribe to Feed Feeds
Keep up with Steph's Closet!

Page Generated in 0.12 seconds